11692 2017-06-20 18:10:55 +0000 Recipe sub-pkg RDEPENDS being installed in image even with sub-pkg is not 2017-06-28 02:20:27 +0000 1 1 7 Build System, Metadata & Runtime BitBake bitbake unspecified x86 Multiple RESOLVED NOTABUG Medium normal 2.4 1 mark.asselstine mark.asselstine jku mark.hatle poky.bs.watcher poky.watcher ross.burton --- Unknown (Hard to categorize) No (bug/feature does not impact docs) oldest_to_newest 74392 0 mark.asselstine 2017-06-20 18:10:55 +0000 If I create a recipe which has additional PACKAGES added and distinct RDEPENDS are added to this 'sub' package. Then install only the main pkg (not the sub-pkg) the RDEPENDS will be included in the image despite no actual dependencies. So for example I can create a simple recipe such as ---meta/recipes-extended/sample/sample_1.0.bb--- LICENSE = "CLOSED" LIC_FILES_CHKSUM = "" PACKAGES += "${PN}-extra" S = "${WORKDIR}" RDEPENDS_${PN}-extra += "findutils" # No information for SRC_URI yet (only an external source tree was specified) SRC_URI = "file://sample.txt" # NOTE: no Makefile found, unable to determine what needs to be done do_configure () { # Specify any needed configure commands here : } do_compile () { # Specify compilation commands here : } do_install () { install -d ${D}/${datadir}/${BPN} install ${S}/sample.txt ${D}/${datadir}/${BPN}/. } --- [create the needed sample.txt file] Then setup a bog standard yocto build by sourcing 'oe-init-build-env'. Edit the local.conf to include [CORE_IMAGE_EXTRA_INSTALL += "sample"]. Build and run. You will discover that findutils is installed and available in the rootfs image, since the -extra sub-pkg is not being requested to be included in the image, this is unexpected. NOTE: this is using dnf, as per the default build setup. 74393 1 3834 mark.asselstine 2017-06-20 18:13:40 +0000 Created attachment 3834 Sample recipe 74470 2 ross.burton 2017-06-22 14:47:39 +0000 Do you have dev-pkgs or dbg-pkgs enabled in the image? 74471 3 ross.burton 2017-06-22 14:54:04 +0000 With the sample recipe, PN-extras isn't generated so anything there is a red herring. My hunch is that you've dev-pkgs IMAGE_FEATURE enabled which means that sample-dev is installed. As dev packages depend on the -dev form of all build dependencies this means that sample-dev RDEPENDS on findutils-dev, which depends on findutils. Marking as NEEDINFO, Mark can you verify that this hypothesis is correct or not. 74553 4 mark.asselstine 2017-06-26 18:53:55 +0000 Ross, 'bitbake core-image-minimal -e' where I have CORE_IMAGE_EXTRA_INSTALL += "sample", I see: IMAGE_FEATURES="debug-tweaks ptest-pkgs" My sample may not be complete enough but if you do add to it the outcome remains the same. The presence of the sub-pkg RDEPENDS will cause these pkgs to be installed in the image. 74577 5 jku 2017-06-27 16:13:39 +0000 (In reply to comment #4) > My sample may not be complete enough but if you do add to it the outcome > remains the same. The presence of the sub-pkg RDEPENDS will cause these pkgs > to be installed in the image. There's probably something else still at play here -- adding "sample" to an image just doesn't bring findutils with it here. 74579 6 mark.asselstine 2017-06-27 20:18:58 +0000 (In reply to comment #5) > (In reply to comment #4) > > My sample may not be complete enough but if you do add to it the outcome > > remains the same. The presence of the sub-pkg RDEPENDS will cause these pkgs > > to be installed in the image. > > There's probably something else still at play here -- adding "sample" to an > image just doesn't bring findutils with it here. I am checking the 'sample' recipe again. I might have to abandon it in favour of the real recipe I am seeing this with (openvswitch in meta-virt). Will let you know. 74580 7 3846 mark.asselstine 2017-06-27 20:36:33 +0000 Created attachment 3846 updated sample .bb 74581 8 mark.asselstine 2017-06-27 20:41:01 +0000 (In reply to comment #6) > (In reply to comment #5) > > (In reply to comment #4) > > > My sample may not be complete enough but if you do add to it the outcome > > > remains the same. The presence of the sub-pkg RDEPENDS will cause these pkgs > > > to be installed in the image. > > > > There's probably something else still at play here -- adding "sample" to an > > image just doesn't bring findutils with it here. > > I am checking the 'sample' recipe again. I might have to abandon it in > favour of the real recipe I am seeing this with (openvswitch in meta-virt). > Will let you know. OK, attached is the updated sample .bb which matches more closely the recipe I encountered this issue with. Note that I still only have CORE_IMAGE_EXTRA_INSTALL += "sample" yet you can see that findutils is being installed Installing : findutils-4.6.0-r0.i586 6/17 I am investigating ptest.bbclass for clues as it seems to be involved, though I thought I had seen this reproduced without ptest. Mark 74582 9 mark.asselstine 2017-06-27 20:57:17 +0000 Still having trouble making the 'sample' recipe behave in the way I am seeing with the openvswitch recipe. Rather than waste folks time let me do some more investigation and update the case once I can put together a proper reproducer. 74588 10 mark.asselstine 2017-06-28 02:20:27 +0000 I went back and looked at the dependencies closer after failing to make the sample recipe behave the same as the recipe I was seeing the issue, looking more closely at Ross' comment #2. Turns out findutils was being pulled in via the -dev package. 3834 2017-06-20 18:13:40 +0000 2017-06-20 18:13:40 +0000 Sample recipe 11692.tar.bz2 application/x-bzip 947 mark.asselstine QlpoOTFBWSZTWXY0zTMAArF/hMmwAEB8b/+SP+/egP/v3+oAAIBIUAO+WTFALYDhKKZNDVPKPI0n qMQ2oBkAyNNGgYjQAGplMZVPzUp7UQ9QyZAGgAAAAADQ4aaZGIwmmAhgE0wjBMTIaZGhoDhppkYj CaYCGATTCMExMhpkaGgEpoRNBACMpmlDQDaTGoeo02phpM1Gm1PU/kPh+245DmPCoIyTMwrAzMcO fm6IAgsdHQ61PL2MgTNtBMzM4YjepfMc73XA4pnlfUc9x2r2/37rl7Uckqo/hJwoD3DjDSpnlnsi 2GGXNTDKGSHDjokomsrAoQFtGWP60M74nCaRIKYQ7qG9SV5hGPIiIwN4uk9DkOI5qrRDRCmUPqQf RGKaFmWLX7tGs5SYPqo2+r32Ynyvu0SakSQriWBRsUFW19qjhz71OQ3ES8h+4SAToGmmSBWEAldy XGjRijAmLd2Nuzz36kasaFbmFIUpbIKZF4GdAHm834+ryA1AEyAVDqq/n9AG+QqFxKYOpbgvD9cH YUlC56hDy1rZyhPW4F19ssICbh75HiXFcICTifka8vSmVPf7esj8G2mXeGGgfKQSZ3nanqKTXEwZ tBOYKHExChnI2t0Fg5rIlQ+I+1CZaA7sjaWr8dwtpOB3Y5rUvag9OU1VIMaj4G4eY5kag7G5g/i5 dYewhrQe6fkoanfb9AI7UHzEd6uD2SA79/yz1sfuaZsevAtb0obsECaxrL2GlslvE6INm6e6CQTJ IOAnC/C3ZomSp9DVLiFRkq7Ny+EnLE7FV9C7qFfFUxuvfHlowWVMQXkQ0w9OFsuWAjSKpi3Tdpam jC7Jw0HiCDJNI+nVpBylq9tSwWst4aka+Athp6q8BOiJcqmq0MwjM3FMT9MQe+Rw/NbTunkByNXO oYvum4k2PupoitVMgYNd2Vq0NYCEjcosS4tW04tgR69Va2knViPAwC1zjKs3E57jK2pEgINV52jX A+wLJM0WnfGNaOvq7VAhyIdaC/0XUilEz1ByJVzOOwydpIZBIb9SG86NwXG+85BsAo5v5LLiX0cW zIniUyKXLFo6RDsQMZtAI0tmNTQQzyoz5jxgtme+CwF14k9+LWWsQTR4tolh0YgLVdiPhEMTjM0Z woU8MVhBYy04MidBjaAoUYJdpCVhgma1760TkjC9saMGGA+Jp6WyM/Em+56QjiRO3wDdFcy3Qwmh mxsZn0PmmbpQk3gMcPK3lc3nUPzeNmZv4u5IpwoSDsaZpmA= 3846 2017-06-27 20:36:33 +0000 2017-06-27 20:36:33 +0000 updated sample .bb sample_2.0.bb.bz2 application/x-bzip 757 mark.asselstine QlpoOTFBWSZTWY0LfsQAAHpfgAAwfG+AEj/v3oC/79/qQAL9ZgLaurmDVPQET01N6pk0NAaAAABo AamTJkaSmymjTQaAAAAAA0NVPTKZANAAAAAAABKaQjQKnmk8mpNk0mQ09E02jI0I9IgOR3nyOUuW OzxXvDOWTbet3v5TzVUNamKzSZBxIc4iJ4MFIkbDUNCaczHk9z3AVEBNXjhZ+jXPU5bmsIOYY8mN HJ0MNc60FFNBkSMdhwHDvegvQOZL92CYtcoYl9Mz4e92wOIsEninyVrZ2te25lWGkpchGRGl8tXJ BQV7MKu47GbqG7BDdoQCfFx4A7Vpvt0V9oRgmuPrqqKefBqBjZByWc6iiv9IN+7aHQ2J36SBwJ2D z31B3N6CLdzdPnwM5rvoLiTG8nGPA0HXzCUj1HwQmWYbjaYE6PUxEYEazjZdOVTSHlkX0ECwoHrM R4wbOHiHZLw8x22bThH4UBpctrP6IP8I5LzpXLldKZ5GaMzPYU5hDbxAmpIFLBFrFpE6IF/NH4IE QTJZD1Vz8boxvFQdIUlRBUCVOjBe0RomkFQ8xfSimmghqnGhQHJYALpIJM10vfaPEFQOg1sOBclZ scgoAQHlAsIOwpqwOygywR3JaAUwPiwEh4OSTSaDMIsbWmI7IQIEnDcrw+JYA5DN0JMETVNChOia U2zTpQkKvN6CkgSwDAYBEwgUJcqDs0k9OXUtLF6gyiGsyZ7l1jtQxBHPCc5ErYenOZ52RzI3T0iL JGhYEssgfse4ucqMoYq9GDBEVkeCMgiGNyG70aGKTGo5hqwk5jomtRVJxX2kdQ6cHPWRDnChignw w3CKiUJUIIaVTSglWjAiEShVd7yDlnBAIpzfFD5pHnaAdpzkElCJNRJQeUfwhEKownWTGFzC1UoC AEzkqaZQ5SlWx7JBMCEWleTBZY9pf7NaZtZGql5QRqIRyxeVqxgwmgV0lr/R7YxpihIPlgNR1htc yDwBzpP+LuSKcKEhGhb9iA==