6930 2014-11-04 15:38:11 +0000 non GPLv3 build selects wrong recipe when license specifies GPLv3+ 2015-03-13 08:42:48 +0000 1 1 7 Build System, Metadata & Runtime OE-Core core 1.7 x86 Multiple VERIFIED FIXED TC needed High normal 1.7.1 1 holger.behrens sgw akuster alexandru.c.georgescu bluelightning meta.mr.watcher meta.watcher poky.bs.watcher poky.watcher ross.burton costin.c.constantin --- Regression (Used to work) No (bug/feature does not impact docs) oldest_to_newest 46745 0 2225 holger.behrens 2014-11-04 15:38:11 +0000 Created attachment 2225 license.manifest Using YP 1.7 (dizzy), build core-image-minimal with INCOMPATIBLE_LICENSE = "GPLv3" in local.conf; to make sure that readline is added to the image I added IMAGE_INSTALL_append = " gnupg" to local.conf Once build is done, check the license.manifest, e.g. tmp/deploy/licenses/core-image-minimal-qemux86-20141104134601/license.manifest Searching for GPLv3 reveals this: PACKAGE NAME: libreadline6 PACKAGE VERSION: 6.3 RECIPE NAME: readline LICENSE: GPLv3+ So instead of readline_5.2.bb (which is GPLv2) readline_6.3.bb is selected even so it is a non GPLv3 build. 46746 1 bluelightning 2014-11-04 15:53:01 +0000 This is a regression in 1.7 and may relate to the canonicalisation of licenses. A patch relating to this was submitted recently and does appear to resolve the issue: http://git.yoctoproject.org/cgit/cgit.cgi/poky/commit/?id=8c051c8c318b5dba8da968850dccd64238d19619 If this is indeed the correct fix it will need to be backported to the dizzy branch. 46757 2 bluelightning 2014-11-05 12:09:53 +0000 Richard has now applied the above patch to the dizzy branch for 1.7.1: http://git.yoctoproject.org/cgit/cgit.cgi/poky/commit/?h=dizzy&id=f3a177cf045b19612b7d2c96889ac24307191c3d 46758 3 bluelightning 2014-11-05 12:13:39 +0000 For clarity, this doesn't just affect readline, it affects any recipe where license ends in + and isn't already in SPDX form (i.e. "GPLv3+" when INCOMPATIBLE_LICENSE = "GPLv3"). I've updated the title of the bug accordingly. 49442 4 costin.c.constantin 2015-03-13 08:42:48 +0000 Hello, Tested as on comment#1 both on dizzy (93e3df91aaebd48b9c4af946247f3488681d32b6) and on master (c60786cec04230cc4318d269d29029de76012fb0) on Ubuntu 14.10. Everything is fine. Marking as verified. cosscat@ubnt:/media/yp_builds/poky/build/tmp/deploy/licenses/core-image-minimal-qemux86-20150313075039$ grep -i gpl3 license.manifest cosscat@ubnt:/media/yp_builds/poky/build/tmp/deploy/licenses/core-image-minimal-qemux86-20150313075039$ pwd /media/yp_builds/poky/build/tmp/deploy/licenses/core-image-minimal-qemux86-20150313075039 Costin 2225 2014-11-04 15:38:11 +0000 2014-11-04 15:38:11 +0000 license.manifest license.manifest text/cache-manifest 3204 holger.behrens UEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiBiYXNlLWZpbGVzClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMy4wLjE0ClJFQ0lQRSBO QU1FOiBiYXNlLWZpbGVzCkxJQ0VOU0U6IEdQTHYyCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IGJhc2UtcGFzc3dk ClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMy41LjI5ClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiBiYXNlLXBhc3N3ZApMSUNFTlNF OiBHUEx2MisKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogYnVzeWJveApQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDEuMjIuMQpS RUNJUEUgTkFNRTogYnVzeWJveApMSUNFTlNFOiBHUEx2MiBiemlwMgoKUEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiBi dXN5Ym94LWh3Y2xvY2sKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxLjIyLjEKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IGJ1c3li b3gKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIgYnppcDIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogYnVzeWJveC1zeXNsb2cKUEFD S0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxLjIyLjEKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IGJ1c3lib3gKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIg YnppcDIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogYnVzeWJveC11ZGhjcGMKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxLjIy LjEKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IGJ1c3lib3gKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIgYnppcDIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFN RTogZ251cGcKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxLjQuNwpSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogZ251cGcKTElDRU5T RTogR1BMdjIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogZ3BndgpQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDEuNC43ClJFQ0lQ RSBOQU1FOiBnbnVwZwpMSUNFTlNFOiBHUEx2MgoKUEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiBpbml0LWlmdXBkb3du ClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMS4wClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiBpbml0LWlmdXBkb3duCkxJQ0VOU0U6 IEdQTHYyCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IGluaXRzY3JpcHRzClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMS4wClJF Q0lQRSBOQU1FOiBpbml0c2NyaXB0cwpMSUNFTlNFOiBHUEx2MgoKUEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiBpbml0 c2NyaXB0cy1mdW5jdGlvbnMKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxLjAKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IGluaXRz Y3JpcHRzCkxJQ0VOU0U6IEdQTHYyCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IGtlcm5lbC0zLjE0LjE5LXlvY3Rv LXN0YW5kYXJkClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMy4xNC4xOStnaXRBVVRPSU5DK2ZiNjI3MWE5NDJf ZTE5YTFiNDBkZQpSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogbGludXgteW9jdG8KTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIKClBBQ0tB R0UgTkFNRToga2VybmVsLW1vZHVsZS11dmVzYWZiClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMy4xNC4xOStn aXRBVVRPSU5DK2ZiNjI3MWE5NDJfZTE5YTFiNDBkZQpSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogbGludXgteW9jdG8K TElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogbGliYmxraWQxClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjog Mi4yNC4yClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiB1dGlsLWxpbnV4CkxJQ0VOU0U6IEdQTHYyKyBMR1BMdjIuMSsg QlNECgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IGxpYmJ6Mi0wClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMS4wLjYKUkVDSVBF IE5BTUU6IGJ6aXAyCkxJQ0VOU0U6IGJ6aXAyCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IGxpYmM2ClBBQ0tBR0Ug VkVSU0lPTjogMi4yMApSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogZ2xpYmMKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIgTEdQTHYyLjEK ClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogbGlia21vZDIKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxOCtnaXRBVVRPSU5DK2Fl NThkZTBmY2IKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IGttb2QKTElDRU5TRTogTEdQTC0yLjErCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5B TUU6IGxpYnJlYWRsaW5lNgpQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDYuMwpSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogcmVhZGxp bmUKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjMrCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IGxpYnRpbmZvNQpQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJ T046IDUuOQpSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogbmN1cnNlcwpMSUNFTlNFOiBNSVQKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTog bGlidXVpZDEKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAyLjI0LjIKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IHV0aWwtbGludXgK TElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIrIExHUEx2Mi4xKyBCU0QKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogbGliejEKUEFDS0FH RSBWRVJTSU9OOiAxLjIuOApSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogemxpYgpMSUNFTlNFOiBabGliCgpQQUNLQUdF IE5BTUU6IG1vZHV0aWxzLWluaXRzY3JpcHRzClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMS4wClJFQ0lQRSBO QU1FOiBtb2R1dGlscy1pbml0c2NyaXB0cwpMSUNFTlNFOiBQRAoKUEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiBuY3Vy c2VzLXRlcm1pbmZvLWJhc2UKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiA1LjkKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IG5jdXJz ZXMKTElDRU5TRTogTUlUCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IG5ldGJhc2UKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiA1 LjIKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IG5ldGJhc2UKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogcGFj a2FnZWdyb3VwLWNvcmUtYm9vdApQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDEuMApSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogcGFj a2FnZWdyb3VwLWNvcmUtYm9vdApMSUNFTlNFOiBNSVQKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogcnVuLXBvc3Rp bnN0cwpQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDEuMApSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogcnVuLXBvc3RpbnN0cwpMSUNF TlNFOiBNSVQKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogc3lzdmluaXQKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAyLjg4ZHNm ClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiBzeXN2aW5pdApMSUNFTlNFOiBHUEx2MisKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogc3lz dmluaXQtaW5pdHRhYgpQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDIuODhkc2YKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IHN5c3Zp bml0LWluaXR0YWIKTElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogc3lzdmluaXQtcGlkb2YK UEFDS0FHRSBWRVJTSU9OOiAyLjg4ZHNmClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiBzeXN2aW5pdApMSUNFTlNFOiBH UEx2MisKClBBQ0tBR0UgTkFNRTogdWRldgpQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDE4MgpSRUNJUEUgTkFN RTogdWRldgpMSUNFTlNFOiBHUEx2Mi4wKwoKUEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiB1ZGV2LWNhY2hlClBBQ0tB R0UgVkVSU0lPTjogMTgyClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiB1ZGV2CkxJQ0VOU0U6IEdQTHYyLjArIExHUEx2 Mi4xKwoKUEFDS0FHRSBOQU1FOiB1cGRhdGUtYWx0ZXJuYXRpdmVzLW9wa2cKUEFDS0FHRSBWRVJT SU9OOiAwLjEuOCtnaXRBVVRPSU5DK2VhZTBkOGZhNDQKUkVDSVBFIE5BTUU6IG9wa2ctdXRpbHMK TElDRU5TRTogR1BMdjIrCgpQQUNLQUdFIE5BTUU6IHVwZGF0ZS1yYy5kClBBQ0tBR0UgVkVSU0lP TjogMC43ClJFQ0lQRSBOQU1FOiB1cGRhdGUtcmMuZApMSUNFTlNFOiBHUEx2MisKClBBQ0tBR0Ug TkFNRTogdjg2ZApQQUNLQUdFIFZFUlNJT046IDAuMS4xMApSRUNJUEUgTkFNRTogdjg2ZApMSUNF TlNFOiBHUEx2MgoK