Bug 3690

Summary:	Clutter - Unable to find suitable fbconfig for the GLX context
Product:	[Build System, Metadata & Runtime] OE-Core	Reporter:	Alexandru Georgescu <alexandru.c.georgescu>
Component:	graphics	Assignee:	Scott Garman <scott.a.garman>
Status:	VERIFIED WONTFIX	QA Contact:
Severity:	major
Priority:	Medium	CC:	meta.mr.watcher, meta.watcher, sgw
Version:	1.2.2
Target Milestone:	1.2.2
Hardware:	x86
OS:	Multiple
Whiteboard:
OS type for building Yocto:	---	Type of Regression:	---
Verified:		Documentation change:	---

Description Alexandru Georgescu 2013-01-08 15:53:14 UTC

ENVIRONMENT USED: Ubuntu 12.10 64bit
Branch: denzil 
commit: 1d05505e0653aa70f7e38239951b4e19ce0438e1
Autobuilder: http://autobuilder.pokylinux.org/nightly/20130105-1

toolchain: http://autobuilder.pokylinux.org/nightly/20130105-1/toolchain/x86_64/poky-eglibc-x86_64-i586-toolchain-gmae-1.2.2.tar.bz2

qemux86: http://autobuilder.pokylinux.org/nightly/20130105-1/machines/qemu/qemux86/core-image-sato-sdk-qemux86-20130105014903.rootfs.tar.bz2


STEPS TO REPRODUCE:

1. Install the x86 standalone toolchain
2. Configure Eclipse Indigo with 1.2 Eclipse plugin.
3. Install the standalone i586 toolchain.
3. Download and extract qemux86.

In Eclipse:

4. Configure Eclipse Yocto Project ADT settings with the toolchain, and qemu paths.
5. Create a new Clutter C or C++ project
6. Reconfigure project.
7. Build Project.
8. Run the project:
   Run->Run Configurations (make sure a TCF connection is available for connecting to QEMU).

In Run Configurations Window:

9. Enter "Remote Absolute File Path for C/C++ Application"
10. for "Commands to execute before application" enter: $ export DISPLAY=:0.0
11. Press "Run"

EXPECTED RESULTS:
11. The clutter application is deployed to the qemux86 image and it runs correctly

ACTUAL RESULTS:
11. The following error output appears in Eclipse:


 
echo $PWD'>'
export DISPLAY=:0.0;/home/root/j2;exit
root@qemux86:/# echo $PWD'>
'
/>
root@qemux86:/# export DISPLAY=:0.0;/home/root/
j2;exit
go on...
looking for "glXQueryExtension",
global_glXGetProcAddress request
nbRequestElts=1766
glAddSwapHintRectWIN 1 0
glBeginConditionalRenderNVX 1 0
glBeginDefineVisibilityQueryATI 1 0
glBeginOcclusionQuery 1 0
glBeginSceneEXT 1 0
glBeginUseVisibilityQueryATI 1 0
glBindArraySetARB 1 0
glBinormalArrayEXT 1 0
glBlendEquationSeparateATI 1 0
glBufferRegionEnabled 1 0
glBufferRegionEnabledEXT 1 0
glColor3fVertex3fvSUN 1 0
glColor4fNormal3fVertex3fvSUN 1 0
glColor4ubVertex2fvSUN 1 0
glColor4ubVertex3fvSUN 1 0
glColorPointerListIBM 1 0
glColorPointervINTEL 1 0
glColorTableParameterfvSGI 1 0
glColorTableParameterivSGI 1 0
glColorTableSGI 1 0
glDeformationMap3dSGIX 1 0
glDeformationMap3fSGIX 1 0
glDeleteArraySetsARB 1 0
glDeleteBufferRegion 1 0
glDeleteBufferRegionEXT 1 0
glDeleteFencesAPPLE 1 0
glDeleteOcclusionQueries 1 0
glDeleteVertexArraysAPPLE 1 0
glDeleteVisibilityQueriesATI 1 0
glDisableVertexAttribAPPLE 1 0
glDrawBufferRegion 1 0
glDrawBufferRegionEXT 1 0
glDrawElementsFGL 1 0
glDrawElementsInstancedEXT 1 0
glDrawMeshNV 1 0
glDrawWireTrianglesFGL 1 0
glEdgeFlagPointerListIBM 1 0
glElementPointerAPPLE 1 0
glEnableVertexAttribAPPLE 1 0
glEndConditionalRenderNVX 1 0
glEndDefineVisibilityQueryATI 1 0
glEndOcclusionQuery 1 0
glEndSceneEXT 1 0
glEndUseVisibilityQueryATI 1 0
glFinishAsyncSGIX 1 0
glFinishRenderAPPLE 1 0
glFlushRenderAPPLE 1 0
glFlushVertexArrayRangeAPPLE 1 0
glFogCoordPointerListIBM 1 0
glFogFuncSGIS 1 0
glFragmentColorMaterialEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightfEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightfvEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightiEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightivEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightModelfEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightModelfvEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightModeliEXT 1 0
glFragmentLightModelivEXT 1 0
glFragmentMaterialfEXT 1 0
glFragmentMaterialfvEXT 1 0
glFragmentMaterialiEXT 1 0
glFragmentMaterialivEXT 1 0
glGenArraySetsARB 1 0
glGenFencesAPPLE 1 0
glGenOcclusionQueries 1 0
glGenVertexArraysAPPLE 1 0
glGenVisibilityQueriesATI 1 0
glGetColorTableParameterfvSGI 1 0
glGetColorTableParameterivSGI 1 0
glGetColorTableSGI 1 0
glGetFogFuncSGIS 1 0
glGetFragmentLightfvEXT 1 0
glGetFragmentLightivEXT 1 0
glGetFragmentMaterialfvEXT 1 0
glGetFragmentMaterialivEXT 1 0
glGetImageTransformParameterfvHP 1 0
glGetImageTransformParameterivHP 1 0
glGetListParameterfvSGIX 1 0
glGetListParameterivSGIX 1 0
glGetMapAttribParameterfvNV 1 0
glGetMapAttribParameterivNV 1 0
glGetMapControlPointsNV 1 0
glGetMapParameterfvNV 1 0
glGetMapParameterivNV 1 0
glGetOcclusionQueryiv 1 0
glGetOcclusionQueryuiv 1 0
glGetPixelTexGenParameterfvSGIS 1 0
glGetPixelTexGenParameterivSGIS 1 0
glGetProgramRegisterfvMESA 1 0
glGetQueryObjecti64vEXT 1 0
glGetQueryObjectui64vEXT 1 0
glGetTexFilterFuncSGIS 1 0
glGetTexParameterPointervAPPLE 1 0
glGetUniformOffsetEXT 1 0
glIglooInterfaceSGIX 1 0
glImageTransformParameterfvHP 1 0
glImageTransformParameterivHP 1 0
glIndexPointerListIBM 1 0
glInstrumentsBufferSGIX 1 0
glIsArraySetARB 1 0
glIsOcclusionQuery 1 0
glIsVertexAttribEnabledAPPLE 1 0
glLightEnviEXT 1 0
glListParameterfvSGIX 1 0
glListParameterivSGIX 1 0
glMapControlPointsNV 1 0
glMapParameterfvNV 1 0
glMapParameterivNV 1 0
glMapTexture3DATI 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib1dAPPLE 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib1fAPPLE 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib2dAPPLE 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib2fAPPLE 1 0
glMultiDrawElementArrayAPPLE 1 0
glMultiModeDrawArraysIBM 1 0
glMultiModeDrawElementsIBM 1 0
glPixelTexGenParameterfvSGIS 1 0
glPixelTexGenParameterivSGIS 1 0
glTextureRangeAPPLE 1 0
glVertexAttribIPointerEXT 1 0
glXBindSwapBarrierSGIX 1 0
glXBindTexImageEXT 1 0
glXCopySubBufferMESA 1 0
glXCreateGLXPixmapMESA 1 0
glXCreateGLXPixmapWithConfigSGIX 1 0
glXFreeContextEXT 1 0
glXGetContextIDEXT 1 0
glXGetCurrentDisplayEXT 1 0
glXGetCurrentReadDrawableSGI 1 0
glXGetFBConfigFromVisualSGIX 1 0
glXGetMscRateOML 1 0
glXGetSelectedEventSGIX 1 0
glXGetSyncValuesOML 1 0
glXGetVisualFromFBConfigSGIX 1 0
glXImportContextEXT 1 0
glXJoinSwapGroupSGIX 1 0
glXMakeCurrentReadSGI 1 0
glXQueryContextInfoEXT 1 0
glXQueryMaxSwapBarriersSGIX 1 0
glXReleaseBuffersMESA 1 0
glXReleaseTexImageEXT 1 0
glXSelectEventSGIX 1 0
glXSwapBuffersMscOML 1 0
glXWaitForMscOML 1 0
glXWaitForSbcOML 1 0
looking for "glXQueryExtension",
looking for "glXQueryVersion",
looking for "glXChooseFBConfig",

(j2:663): Clutter-CRITICAL **: Unable to initialize Clutter: Unable to find suitable fbconfig for the GLX context: Failed to find any compatible fbconfigs
unhandled SIGSEGV
logout
glInstrumentsBufferSGIX 1 0
glIsArraySetARB 1 0
glIsOcclusionQuery 1 0
glIsVertexAttribEnabledAPPLE 1 0
glLightEnviEXT 1 0
glListParameterfvSGIX 1 0
glListParameterivSGIX 1 0
glMapControlPointsNV 1 0
glMapParameterfvNV 1 0
glMapParameterivNV 1 0
glMapTexture3DATI 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib1dAPPLE 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib1fAPPLE 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib2dAPPLE 1 0
glMapVertexAttrib2fAPPLE 1 0
glMultiDrawElementArrayAPPLE 1 0
glMultiModeDrawArraysIBM 1 0
glMultiModeDrawElementsIBM 1 0
glPixelTexGenParameterfvSGIS 1 0
glPixelTexGenParameterivSGIS 1 0
glTextureRangeAPPLE 1 0
glVertexAttribIPointerEXT 1 0
glXBindSwapBarrierSGIX 1 0
glXBindTexImageEXT 1 0
glXCopySubBufferMESA 1 0
glXCreateGLXPixmapMESA 1 0
glXCreateGLXPixmapWithConfigSGIX 1 0
glXFreeContextEXT 1 0
glXGetContextIDEXT 1 0
glXGetCurrentDisplayEXT 1 0
glXGetCurrentReadDrawableSGI 1 0
glXGetFBConfigFromVisualSGIX 1 0
glXGetMscRateOML 1 0
glXGetSelectedEventSGIX 1 0
glXGetSyncValuesOML 1 0
glXGetVisualFromFBConfigSGIX 1 0
glXImportContextEXT 1 0
glXJoinSwapGroupSGIX 1 0
glXMakeCurrentReadSGI 1 0
glXQueryContextInfoEXT 1 0
glXQueryMaxSwapBarriersSGIX 1 0
glXReleaseBuffersMESA 1 0
glXReleaseTexImageEXT 1 0
glXSelectEventSGIX 1 0
glXSwapBuffersMscOML 1 0
glXWaitForMscOML 1 0
glXWaitForSbcOML 1 0
looking for "glXQueryExtension",
looking for "glXQueryVersion",
looking for "glXChooseFBConfig",

(j2:663): Clutter-CRITICAL **: Unable to initialize Clutter: Unable to find suitable fbconfig for the GLX context: Failed to find any compatible fbconfigs
unhandled SIGSEGV
logout

Comment 1 Scott Garman 2013-01-10 05:06:44 UTC

I've consulted with Ross Burton on this and he has pointed out that this is due to GL passthrough being broken in QEMU. It's the reason that GL-passthrough has been disabled in danny and later releases.

This is a no-win situation - it is possible to remove qemugl support and fall back to software rendering, but the Mesa software renderer in denzil doesn't support enough GL for clutter to work, either.

Addressing this issue is outside the scope of what we can accomplish in a stable point-release that is this old. Someone from the community will have to take up this issue if it is deemed critical. As such I am marking this as WONTFIX.

Comment 2 Alexandru Georgescu 2013-01-10 10:01:44 UTC

Thanks Scott for the clarification.
I've set it to Verified, Wontfix