Created attachment 1201 [details] these files required to complete the "steps to reproduce" This issue is in reference to the Yocto Project's kernel lab, as presented at ELC 2013: https://www.yoctoproject.org/tools-resources/presentations/working-kernel Following the steps for lab 3, when PACKAGE_CLASSES is set to "package_ipk" the auto-loaded module is not automatically loaded as expected. It does work, however, when the default "package_rpm" is used. I noticed this initially on openSUSE 12.2. I have since upgraded to openSUSE 12.3 and can no longer run these labs because qemu-native fails to build (due to unrelated isssues). I have, however, installed Fedora 18 (64) in a VM and can reproduce these same steps with that distribution. NOTE: openSUSE 12.3 can build qemu-native from poky's HEAD just fine. All of my steps assume you are performing these exercises in /home/trevor/devel/yocto/lab, you'll have to adjust the attached files as necessary for your layout Steps to reproduce: - download https://www.yoctoproject.org/sites/yoctoproject.org/files/elc-2013-layers.tar.bz2 to $HOME $ cd $ tar -xf files.tar [from this issue's attachment] $ mkdir -p $HOME/devel/yocto/lab $ cd /home/trevor/devel/yocto/lab $ mkdir lab_rpm $ cd lab_rpm $ git clone git://git.yoctoproject.org/poky.git $ cd poky $ git checkout -b danny remotes/origin/danny $ bzip2 -d < $HOME/elc-2013-layers.tar.bz2 $ source oe-init-build-env $ cp $HOME/files/local.conf conf [edit and adjust paths in conf/local.conf as necessary] $ cp $HOME/files/bblayers.conf conf [edit and adjust paths in conf/bblayers.conf as necessary] $ cp $HOME/files/lab3-qemux86.conf ../meta-lab3-qemux86/conf/machine $ cp $HOME/files/linux-yocto-custom.bb ../meta-lab3-qemux86/recipes-kernel/linux $ bitbake core-image-minimal $ runqemu tmp/deploy/images/bzImage-lab3-qemux86.bin tmp/deploy/images/core-image-minimal-lab3-qemux86.ext3 When the image comes up, login as root and run: # lsmod In this case you'll see that the yocto module is loaded (as expected) Now terminate your shell. Starting with a brand-new shell repeat all of the above steps again. This time, however, do your work in /home/trevor/devel/yocto/lab/lab_ipk instead. Also, when you adjust your conf/local.conf, switch the PACKAGE_CLASSES to "package_ipk" from the default "package_rpm". This time when you log into your image and run "lsmod" there won't be any kernel modules loaded. NOTE: when performing these exact steps with poky's HEAD (instead of using the danny branch) everything works just fine whether the packaging is rpm or ipk.
I'm changing the summary from "elc-2013 kernel lab: lab3 fails if PACKAGE_CLASSES = package_ipk" to better reflect the problem. Because the labs need to be upgraded anyway for dylan, doing that will fix this problem for users and a new bug has been opened for that: https://bugzilla.yoctoproject.org/show_bug.cgi?id=4440 The root problem however still needs to be fixed in danny.
This is a danny bug, move to danny.
Tom, I've not looked at the kernel lab yet, do you have a hunch as to what the problem could be?
No idea, but I'll look into it now..
In danny with ipk, there is no /etc/modules file, and /etc/init.d/modutils.sh only looks at /etc/modules when autoloading modules. In danny with rpm, /etc/modules exists and /etc/init.d/modutils.sh finds it and loads the modules listed there, including our yocto-testmod module from the lab. In dylan with ipk, there is still no /etc/modules, but there is /etc/modules-load.d/*.conf files including our yocto-testmod.conf from the lab. /etc/init.d/modutils.sh in dylan has been changed to autoload the modules named in the *.conf files listed in /etc/init.d/modutils.sh, so in this case correctly autoloads the test module from the lab. In danny with ipk, the /etc/modules-load.d/yocto-testmod.conf file for the lab is there, but modutils.sh in danny doesn't look for it, but /etc/modules instead, so doesn't autoload the module. So, either figure out why /etc/modules doesn't get generated in the ipk case, or bring the modutils.sh change that reads /etc/modules-load.d from dylan to danny.
So it seems /etc/modules doesn't get created because update-modules doesn't get run at postinstall, because we're using core-image-minimal for the lab, which doesn't have package-management and therefore doesn't run postinstalls. I believe this bug describes the problem: Bug 4484 - Postinstalls don't run for ipk if package-management is disabled So marking this bug as blocking on 4484.
Please see bug 4484 for a more detailed explanation, but the proper fix for this doesn't seem trivial: https://bugzilla.yoctoproject.org/show_bug.cgi?id=4484 There are a couple hacks that can work around this, but they don't seem like things that would be accepted into danny. Because this is a problem that goes back at least to denzil, it's also not a regression, so for that reason as well wouldn't normally be a candidate for a point release either. Also, because this is not a problem in dylan and because the kernel lab has been updated to dylan, the easy workaround is to use the new dylan kernel lab: https://www.yoctodev.org/tools-resources/training/kernel-lab If this is really still a problem anyone thinks is something we need to put resources into to fix in danny, please let me know, and I'll open a brand new bug with the same title as 4484 but for danny.