Created attachment 2248 [details] local.conf Hello, While performing TC 295 - Use buildhistory-diff to analyse changes for 2 builds , having the following content: " 1. build some recipes and get the buildhistory log(for example, recipe "xcursor-transparent-theme") with INHERIT += "buildhistory" and BUILDHISTORY_COMMIT = "1" in local.conf 2. change the PR of xcursor-transparent-theme backwards, for example from "r4" to "r3" 3. re-build the recipe and run buildhistory-diff to check if there is any change " the buildhistory-diff tool is not working. I performed the steps as instructed on step 1 and on step 2 (after modifying meta-yocto/conf/distro/poky.conf adding "version-going-backwards" to WARN_QA): [cosscat@Fedora-CCC build]$ bitbake xcursor-transparent-theme Loading cache: 100% |####################################################################################################################################################################################################| ETA: 00:00:00 Loaded 1222 entries from dependency cache. Parsing recipes: 100% |##################################################################################################################################################################################################| Time: 00:00:00 Parsing of 862 .bb files complete (861 cached, 1 parsed). 1221 targets, 38 skipped, 0 masked, 0 errors. NOTE: Resolving any missing task queue dependencies Build Configuration: BB_VERSION = "1.22.0" BUILD_SYS = "x86_64-linux" NATIVELSBSTRING = "Fedora-20" TARGET_SYS = "i586-poky-linux" MACHINE = "qemux86" DISTRO = "poky" DISTRO_VERSION = "1.6.2" TUNE_FEATURES = "m32 i586" TARGET_FPU = "" meta meta-yocto meta-yocto-bsp = "(detachedfrom30b8d93):30b8d9378b8260e452552b806610dc9b6fe0b69f" NOTE: Preparing runqueue NOTE: Executing SetScene Tasks WARNING: QA Issue: Package version for package xcursor-transparent-theme-dbg went backwards which would break package feeds from (0:0.1.1-r4 to 0:0.1.1-r3) WARNING: QA Issue: Package version for package xcursor-transparent-theme-staticdev went backwards which would break package feeds from (0:0.1.1-r4 to 0:0.1.1-r3) WARNING: QA Issue: Package version for package xcursor-transparent-theme-dev went backwards which would break package feeds from (0:0.1.1-r4 to 0:0.1.1-r3) WARNING: QA Issue: Package version for package xcursor-transparent-theme-doc went backwards which would break package feeds from (0:0.1.1-r4 to 0:0.1.1-r3) WARNING: QA Issue: Package version for package xcursor-transparent-theme-locale went backwards which would break package feeds from (0:0.1.1-r4 to 0:0.1.1-r3) WARNING: QA Issue: Package version for package xcursor-transparent-theme went backwards which would break package feeds from (0:0.1.1-r4 to 0:0.1.1-r3) NOTE: Executing RunQueue Tasks NOTE: Tasks Summary: Attempted 237 tasks of which 236 didn't need to be rerun and all succeeded. NOTE: Writing buildhistory ... then tried buildhistory-diff with the following result: [cosscat@Fedora-CCC build]$ buildhistory-diff Unable to find previous build revision in buildhistory repository Usage: buildhistory-diff [options] [from-revision [to-revision]] (if not specified, from-revision defaults to build-minus-1, and to-revision defaults to HEAD) Reports significant differences in the buildhistory repository. Options: -h, --help show this help message and exit -p BUILDHISTORY_DIR, --buildhistory-dir=BUILDHISTORY_DIR Specify path to buildhistory directory (defaults to buildhistory/ under cwd) -v, --report-version Report changes in PKGE/PKGV/PKGR even when the values are still the default (PE/PV/PR) -a, --report-all Report all changes, not just the default significant ones [cosscat@Fedora-CCC build]$ ls bitbake.lock buildhistory cache conf downloads sstate-cache tmp I also tried with explicit directory: [cosscat@Fedora-CCC build]$ buildhistory-diff -p buildhistory but same result. For reference the local.conf file is attached. Costin
Hello, I forgot to add that I tested this on 3 different machines: 1x Fedore 20 1x Ubuntu desktop 14.04 1x Ubuntu server 14.04 ... all behaved the same Costin
I cannot reproduce this with daisy on either a CentOS 6 or an Ubuntu 14.04 machine. I am attempting the following: 1. bitbake xcursor-transparent-theme 2. Change PR in the recipe from "r4" to "r3" 3. bitbake xcursor-transparent-theme 4. Run buildhistory-diff I've also tried both with an existing buildhistory directory and without. Can you check to see if any commits are being made at all in the buildhistory directory?
Costin, can you check?
Hello, I just tried again (with latest commit given to be tested: 6dd21a9f152a93e2df1178d7a5bd903d7edcf4be) both with an existing copy of poky and with a new one (though should be no difference) on an Ubuntu 14.10. The buildhistory dir is created alongside with its subdirs: cosscat@ubnt:/media/poky/3poky/build$ df -h buildhistory/ Filesystem Size Used Avail Use% Mounted on /dev/md0 793G 108G 646G 15% /media/poky cosscat@ubnt:/media/poky/3poky/build$ du -h buildhistory/ 12K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme 8,0K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-staticdev 8,0K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-dbg 8,0K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-doc 8,0K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-dev 8,0K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-locale 60K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme 64K buildhistory/packages/all-poky-linux 68K buildhistory/packages 8,0K buildhistory/.git/logs/refs/heads 12K buildhistory/.git/logs/refs 20K buildhistory/.git/logs 4,0K buildhistory/.git/refs/tags 8,0K buildhistory/.git/refs/heads 16K buildhistory/.git/refs 44K buildhistory/.git/hooks 8,0K buildhistory/.git/info 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/fd 4,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/pack 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/71 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/37 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/66 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/78 4,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/info 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/b5 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/07 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/35 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/5a 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/18 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/2e 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/bf 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/b3 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/91 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/64 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/76 8,0K buildhistory/.git/objects/ee 12K buildhistory/.git/objects/f5 160K buildhistory/.git/objects 4,0K buildhistory/.git/branches 276K buildhistory/.git 352K buildhistory/ cosscat@ubnt:/media/poky/3poky/build$ Regarding commits, the given commit is taken into consideration: cosscat@ubnt:/media/poky/3poky/build/buildhistory$ cat metadata-revs meta = (detachedfrom6dd21a9):6dd21a9f152a93e2df1178d7a5bd903d7edcf4be meta-yocto = (detachedfrom6dd21a9):6dd21a9f152a93e2df1178d7a5bd903d7edcf4be meta-yocto-bsp = (detachedfrom6dd21a9):6dd21a9f152a93e2df1178d7a5bd903d7edcf4be meta-intel = master:a72da6350e7a77256ad597e8e8c40909590a2a40 cosscat@ubnt:/media/poky/3poky/build/buildhistory$ Costin
Hello, I have the same issue on 1.6.3 RC4: b2ba41b57550aa912da93b4aef789ff562a67fce. This time, after building the xcursor-transparent-theme for rc4 i erased tmp, cache and sstate-cache dirs and then rebuilt for r3 Costin
I'm still struggling to reproduce this - Costin I am going to need your help.
Hi Pual, After your recommendation with http://git.yoctoproject.org/cgit/cgit.cgi/poky-contrib/commit/?h=paule/buildhistory-fix&id=dcaf857899f76f5c41fe0d4ae1d83b5e7ef7f87d It worked fine. Here is the result: [cosscat@Fedora-CCC build]$ buildhistory-diff packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-dev: RDEPENDS: removed "xcursor-transparent-theme (['= 0.1.1-r4'])" added "xcursor-transparent-theme (['= 0.1.1-r3'])" * PR changed from "r4" to "r3" packages/all-poky-linux/xcursor-transparent-theme/xcursor-transparent-theme-staticdev: RDEPENDS: removed "xcursor-transparent-theme-dev (['= 0.1.1-r4'])" added "xcursor-transparent-theme-dev (['= 0.1.1-r3'])" * PR changed from "r4" to "r3" [cosscat@Fedora-CCC build]$ Please let me know when to mark the bug as Verified. (after merging the patch i guess) Costin
With access to Constin's setup I was able to see that the problem was that user.email and user.name weren't set in git's configuration (which git was complaining about at the end of the build). This isn't covered in the manual though and buildhistory ought to set these locally for the repository if the user hasn't done it globally. I've just sent a patch to the OE-Core list to do that.
Fixed in f62255bfa6c5a322c867b7c4ea5686ea7bfab3fe.
*** Bug 7807 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
verified at the time: no status changed