The git fetcher will download a tarball from a mirror if the required ref doesn't exist in a local copy, when what it should really do is update the local copy (which may well be done after the tarball is pulled anyway). We need to re-wire the git fetcher (and possibly the base fetcher implementation) so that if a fullclone or force_fetch are going to trigger a pull from git we will not fetch a tarball first.
Different wording, same bug - Kevin's bug (290) includes repro information so I'll focus tracking efforts there. *** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 290 ***
Definitely a duplicate, bug #290 is fixed too.